Log in

View Full Version : P33 - Partial win and fumble at the same time !?



Tontione
04-23-2013, 04:57 PM
Partial win table result, p33 :
Stand vs charge - Unit commander fumbled.

If the unit commander fumbled, it can't be a partial win !?
So does stand vs charge must be removed from this table ?

Another strange thing on the same table :
Stand fast - Unit commander lost the battle roll
No need to say that if it's a partial win !?
Stand fast chapter p43 says that "the unit commander has failed his battle roll".
fail = loss ? so in this case, stand fast must be removed from partial win table. Otherwise change the sentence on stand fast chapter.

The same is on loss table, no need to say that here too, because it's a loss ...

Lothaire
04-26-2013, 10:19 AM
If the unit commander fumbles his battle roll, there is no partial success. Thats right. But if he manages a partial success, there is no reason, why he should not choose a voluntary stand vs. charge. I would consider stand fast a wiser choice, but that doesnt matter as long as I am not this unit leader.